Why don't people like Silent Hill: Homecoming?

I just finished it for the 2nd time, and gotta admit I like it now even better than before.

It was my first (and only) Silent Hill game I've played. Seeing it get 6/10s on Wikipedia is kind of sad. It feels like they put a lot of effort into this game.

I've seen a lot of comparisons to the Silent Hill movie, which I also haven't seen. So yeah, I'm not that big of a Silent Hill fan, but if someone asked me "do I like Silent Hill" then I'd easily respond with "Yeah, I loved Homecoming."

Is it that people think it's a bad Silent Hill game? Do they think it's a bad game in general?

And my biggest question, do you think the game is better in retrospect?